Review: Against the Slave Lords

As is well-known by now, Wizards of the Coast has been re-issuing a number of classic books and adventures in suped-up fancy versions, as well as making more and more of its back catalog available in pdf. While this is certainly laudable and speaks to their intention of serving fans of previous versions as well as new versions (doubtless with an eye towards bringing in the former when D&D Next rolls out next year), I’ve largely skipped the re-issues because I have all the originals, mostly purchased when they first came out.

However, when I heard that WotC was not only reissuing the original A1-4 “Slavers” adventures, but also including a brand-new A0 prequel module, I had to get the book, if only for the sake of completeness.

I have to say I’m pretty impressed.

The new adventure, written by Skip Williams, is A0 “Danger at Darkshelf Quarry”. It takes up 23 of the first 28 pages of the book, and seems to be a suitable way to easy the PCs into the machinations of the Slave Lords (although it takes place in southernmost Nyrond, as opposed to the Wild Coast where the other adventures in the series take place). It’s designed for characters level 1-3, but given that Slave Pits of the Undercity is for levels 4-7, and I don’t really see any way the adventure could jump up PCs 3 or 4 levels, some more intermediate action is probably going to have to be invented by the DM to bridge the gap. One thing I really like is that there’s a mocked-up module cover for Darkshelf Quarry on the back card of the book, done up in a similar style to the other four module covers. That was a nice touch.

The rest of the book is given up to the classic series of 4 modules. It’s not merely a scan of the original; everything has been retyped and formatted to follow the original, although there are obvious discrepancies between the two in terms of where paragraphs begin and end on the page, etc. The book features the wonderful original art and maps from the 1980’s modules, and ends with a gallery of modern fan-art inspired by the series (among whose ranks you’ll find several artists who also appear in the Adventures Dark and Deep™ books). They did a very good job of recreating the original look and feel, and all in all this would be a fine way to introduce the classic series to new players.

The back cover card does indicate that the adventures are “Playable with D&D Next rules found at”. However, there are no mechanics for the new version of the game in the book; to use it with the new rules one must download a conversion packet from the website. Even the new adventure is written using the 1st edition rules. I didn’t see any module conversion notes in my copy of the latest playtest packet, but I did see a bestiary with D&D Next stats for the various A0-4 monsters (well, A0-5; apparently this month’s Dungeon magazine will feature another new adventure, “The Last Slave Lord”).

On the whole, I’m very pleased with this book, and will probably want to integrate Darkshelf Quarry into my next Greyhawk campaign.

Written by 

Wargamer and RPG'er since the 1970's, author of Adventures Dark and Deep, Castle of the Mad Archmage, and other things, and proprietor of the Greyhawk Grognard blog.

13 thoughts on “Review: Against the Slave Lords

  1. Thanks for the review. I just bought Dungeon of Dread and plan on getting this one. I love the book, but don't find it friendly for actual play.

  2. Back in the 80s, they repackaged the Slave Lords adventures as a megamodule and sequel to T1-4/Temple of Elemental Evil. It was fun to run but unfortunately a bit underpowered for the expected level of opposition. It was sold as appropriate for 7-11 level but wasn't really different from the originals so veterans of T1-4 would have too easy a time.

  3. Thanks for the review, as always, Joe. Did they fix any of the errata in the original modules (like the lack of a door to enter encounters 9 and 10 in A1, for example)?


  4. I had the same issue with the missing door. I just put one there when I ran it.

    What really sucks is that I'd love to get hold of that A5 "Last of the Slavers" module but I don't want to dump $10 on a DDO subscription for a single article from Dungeon :(.

  5. I just picked this book up. Instead of the fan art, I think they should have printed the dungeon maps as pull-out pages, so I don't have to go flipping back and forth between pages to reference the maps.

  6. Hi,
    I'm planning to run my players through these modules – I like the campaign with a larger purpose idea. I've already taken them through a 0-level adventure, N4 Treasure Hunt, which started with them being taken prisoner by slaver-pirates which seemed appropriate, and they've just started A0 Danger at Darkshelf Quarry. After A0 I was planning to run an adventure separate from the Slavers story (but still keeping the door open for A1) as a palate cleanser. My question is which version of the Slaver series would you recommend? I have access to this new compilation, Against the Slave Lords, and to the earlier collection, Scourge of the Slave Lords. Which do you think would work better as part of a campaign? Which is less tournementy and more suitable for a normal adventure?


Comments are closed.